Wednesday, January 21, 2009

We could be both right or wrong

You argue that a liberal drug policy would reduce the number of drug users, because criminals have no incentives to recruit new addicts. Your friend argues that such a policy would lead to a huge increase in drug users, because drugs are freely available. Who is right? Then you dig out the statistics of the Netherlands, a country with a very liberal drug policy, and show your friend that drug use has not increased. You proved him wrong. And claim a win on the debate. But then you re-examine the data and see that the drug use stayed relatively constant defying your argument, too. You were both wrong. Or wait maybe you were both right, because the two effects might balance out?

When two people present statements, there are four scenarios. A is right, B is wrong. A is wrong, and B is right. And both A and B are right, and both A and B are wrong! Often, we get confused, because assume that the two statements are exactly opposite, e.g policy reduces number, or policy does NOT reduce number. However, very often both people hold different opinions but not 100% opposite opinions. You argued that drug use would go down, and your friend that it would go up. In fact, you were both wrong, drug use stayed relatively stable!

Never think that you have won an argument by defeating someone else's arguments. Sure, you have proven them wrong, but your statement could well be wrong or right.

1 comment:

qsbovzt1jm said...

Recently Kangwon Land casino has been made to shut two hours earlier each day to mitigate downside playing. However, on the prime on-line casinos for South Korean players, find a way to|you probably can} gamble 24/7 with out fearing that anyone will put a “compulsive 우리카지노 gambler” tag on you, as is the apply in the one land-based playing house available for local residents. Per present local legal guidelines, Korean residents are prohibited to engage in taking part in} card video games and slot machines in Korea, unless it's in a state-approved casino, like the remote Kangwon Land Casino. Foreigners, the opposite hand|however|then again}, are free togamble and luxuriate in sports activities bettingin over two dozen authorized land-based casinos that local citizens usually are not allowed in. Land-based casinos charge money or chips to let you get pleasure from their video games, however that’s not what all casinos on-line do. Some of the most effective on-line casinos also allow you to play free desk video games and slot machines in Korea, with out asking you to go away the consolation of your sofa.